The Geek Culture Forums
Ask a Geek! Time for a new Save icon?
|
UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
Author | Topic: Time for a new Save icon? |
Super Flippy Geek Posts: 78 |
posted March 06, 2002 12:11
One of our developers has asked me to make him some "cool icons" for his new app. As I began sketching ideas, I realized that I had a problem. The majority of apps I've seen use a floppy disk as the icon for "Save". Now, even if you actually have a floppy drive on your computer, when's the last time you actually used it, let alone saved a file to it from within an application? I'm thinking that perhaps the floppy icon is getting a little long in the tooth. But what else means "Save" and is recognizeable? A hard drive? A baseball glove? Any wacky and interesting ideas out there? IP: Logged |
Tau Zero BlabberMouth, the Next Generation. Posts: 1685 |
posted March 06, 2002 12:59
A life jacket. An animated roll of aluminum foil (as in leftovers). A piggy bank (in a different context). File cabinets are obvious, but they are possibly even more pass� than floppies. IP: Logged |
Bregalad Super Geek Posts: 203 |
posted March 06, 2002 13:18
Actually Tau, the invention of the computer has increased the use of paper (particularly US Letter and A4), making filing cabinets even more necessary than in the past. Viewed from that perspective, however, the filing cabinet could be used as the print icon. Now wouldn't that screw up users? IP: Logged |
quantumfluff Highlie Posts: 672 |
posted March 06, 2002 13:53
Tupperware. A safe. The word "Save" in tiny letters.
IP: Logged |
macadddikt18 SuperBlabberMouth! Posts: 1126 |
posted March 06, 2002 16:06
Jesus saves. and so does superman Nayt ------------------ IP: Logged |
ZorroTheFox SuperBlabberMouth! Posts: 1117 |
posted March 06, 2002 18:05
how about a life saver........Z IP: Logged |
trowelblister Super Geek Posts: 227 |
posted March 06, 2002 19:34
personally, the tupperware idea amuses me the most, and while the file cabinet is probably apropos, it doesn't seem like much fun. not that I have any good suggestions,,,,,, screw it, how expensive can it be to liscense the superman logo from DC comix??? IP: Logged |
pakratt Newbie Posts: 9 |
posted March 06, 2002 23:57
last time i used a floppy disk, last night when i was putting linux on an old 486. however, other than installation boot floppies (i'm one of those people that uses them quite often for hobby) i can't think of the last time i used one. however, a save icon... can't think of anything that's not already said. but i think that's how icons will always be, a reference to how things were in the past. for instance, many applications use binoculars for the find function. have i ever used binoculars to find something, doubtful. when i think of find i think grep or locate or in the non-computer world walking around yelling (i.e. find your brother.) most apps have dot-matrix printers for the print icon which is definitely outdated too. and if you stray too far from the norm you'll just confuse people. wish i could help you more but my advice is stick pretty close to common practice. this is where linux needs major work (there is no common anything in linux) and the other systems should not stray from. IP: Logged |
littlefish Geek Posts: 71 |
posted March 07, 2002 07:14
How about a goalkeeper (for your favourite sport) diving to stop a ball/puck/whatever from finding the back of the net. You could maybe even offer a choice of sports. Or jesus with a halo IP: Logged |
Super Flippy Geek Posts: 78 |
posted March 07, 2002 07:31
Some great ideas! I particularly like the roll of aluminum foil. Or how about a ziploc bag? Actually, I went with a life preserver, since it was easy to squish down tiny. Also, I think I recall seeing a similar icon in long-ago apps (was it Norton?) so I thought it might be familiar. I haven't shown it to the developer yet, so we'll see whether or not this goes over well. I did a search for "save" on my IP: Logged |
dragonman97 Geek Posts: 97 |
posted March 07, 2002 14:21
Well, the only problem is that a life preserver is commonly used as a help icon (in KDE under Linux, and for Norton Rescue Disk under Windoze [that's probably the Norton reference you remember]). A safe is not a bad idea, and I must say that I like the Zip-Lock (tm) bag as a save icon idea. But a floppy does mean save to me, as I still use them every now and then (I don't use Macs much, but just worked on a Powerbook G3, and did a file transfer from a PC to it via floppy. Back on the old IBM XT, while I still used the HD as primary file storage, I would back up routinely to floppy. But then, I recall, PC's didn't crash that much, I mainly used the floppy drive to boot straight into games (Lode Runner, and the original MS Flight Simulator). IP: Logged |
dragonman97 Geek Posts: 97 |
posted March 07, 2002 14:29
pakratt, I'm glad to see another Linux user has joined our ranks. Welcome! IP: Logged |
All times are Pacific Time | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
� 2002 Geek Culture� All Rights Reserved.
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47e